What is the best option for trust building? A research-backed answer

The short answer. The best option for trust building is a shared experience with real stakes, where a team has to solve a problem together and the outcome actually matters. Research from Dr. Paul Zak, published in Harvard Business Review in 2017, found that employees at high-trust companies report seventy-four percent less stress, one hundred six percent more energy at work, fifty percent higher productivity, and forty percent less burnout than employees at low-trust companies. Talking about trust does not produce it. Trust is built by giving people a reason to rely on each other, then watching what happens when they do.

What actually builds trust on teams

Google’s Project Aristotle, a multi-year internal study of more than one hundred eighty teams reported around 2015, set out to find what separated its highest-performing teams from the rest. The answer was not intelligence, tenure, or even friendship. It was psychological safety: the shared belief that a team is safe for interpersonal risk-taking. People had to feel they could speak up, disagree, or admit a mistake without it costing them socially. We take that finding further in building high-performing teams.

That finding lines up with Zak’s neuroscience research, which measured oxytocin release during cooperative tasks and found it correlated directly with trustworthy behavior between people who had just met. The mechanism is behavioral, not aspirational. Trust goes up when people take a risk together and it pays off, not when they are instructed to trust each other. Those figures, with the rest of the evidence we build on, sit on Why Experiential Learning Works.

This is also why Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace: 2023 Report found that only twenty-three percent of employees worldwide were engaged at work. Engagement and trust are tightly linked, and most organizations are trying to close that gap with the wrong tool.

Where classic exercises lose the room

The classic trust fall, the icebreaker questionnaire, and the half-day workshop with a facilitator and a whiteboard fall short because they do not ask anything real of the people in the room. There is no actual risk, no real consequence, and no shared outcome that anyone has to protect afterward.

Adults learn differently than the traditional training model assumes. Decades of adult-learning research, going back to Malcolm Knowles’ andragogy framework, point to the same conclusion: adults retain and apply what they learn through action, reflection, and real-world application, not through lecture or passive discussion. A slide deck about trust can define the word. It cannot produce the feeling of needing a teammate and having them show up. That is the first filter we use when evaluating any experiential program.

This is the gap experiential learning is built to close. When a challenge requires people to depend on each other to succeed, and falling short carries a real cost, the brain and the team respond differently than they do in a seminar room.

The psychological mechanism behind experiential trust building

Trust between adults who barely know each other forms fastest under three conditions: shared risk, visible contribution, and a result everyone can see and feel. When a group of coworkers is handed a problem they genuinely cannot solve alone, something predictable happens. The org chart stops being the most useful map of the room. The quietest person often becomes the one who sees the answer first. People start listening differently, because they need to.

This is the mechanism Morrison Alley designs for. After twenty-five years of building programs for organizations, corporations, and sports teams, the pattern is reliable enough to design around. Every program puts a team inside a genuine challenge, built around a place or story with real history, and gives them a problem that only works if they work together. What comes out of that (the connections formed, the commitments said out loud, the memory of the place they said them in) belongs to the team, not to a facilitator’s script. Ownership of the result is what makes the trust last, which is a different outcome than people remembering what they were told.

Three tests that separate a real experience from a gimmick

Not every offsite or team activity produces trust. The difference comes down to whether the experience has honest stakes and an honest connection to the team’s actual work.

First, the challenge has to require genuine interdependence. If one strong personality can solve the puzzle alone while everyone else watches, nothing changes back at the office. The task has to be built so that contribution has to come from multiple people, often from the person least expected to lead.

Second, the outcome has to carry weight. If there is no real possibility of falling short, there is no real trust being extended. Success and failure need to mean something in the moment, the same way they do in a live project or a close game.

Third, the metaphor has to be honest. A team will not transfer what they learned on a rope course to a quarterly sales target unless the connection between the two is drawn clearly and specifically, not left for people to guess at. If the activity feels decorative, people notice the artifice early, and the trust-building effect goes with it. We make that case in the room is the problem.

How Morrison Alley approaches trust building

Every program we build starts with the people, not the location or the activity. Before anything else, we ask which behaviors actually need to shift, and what has to still be true a year later for the investment to have been worth it. That conversation shapes everything that follows, which is why no two Morrison Alley programs look alike. The same question sits behind what actually works well for company culture.

From there, we find a place with a real story to tell and put the team inside that story, tied directly to what they are facing at work. Then we hand them a problem they cannot solve individually. What they walk away with is not a handout. It is the relationships they built under pressure, the people they now understand differently, and the commitments they made out loud in a place they will not forget.

The work does not stop when the experience ends. We align what happened against the organization’s actual priorities before anyone leaves the room, with named owners and next steps, and follow it with structured practice and spaced reinforcement back at work. Trust built in a single afternoon only holds if the behavior shows up again the following Tuesday. That follow-through is the subject of what makes a leadership program actually stick and of how experiential learning creates lasting behavioral change.

Measuring whether trust building actually worked

A team that trusts each other produces four observable outcomes, and each one is specific enough to check for afterward. Everyone can describe the team’s purpose in roughly the same words. The team has agreed out loud, not just on paper, to a shared direction. The team covers ground faster than a group pointed in different directions ever could. And leaders in the room show they can turn intention into action when the first busy week hits and old habits try to creep back in.

If a trust-building investment does not produce at least the first two of those within a few weeks, the activity entertained people without changing anything. That is the honest bar any option, ours included, should be measured against. For the measurement design behind that bar, see how to measure experiential leadership development.

Choosing the right format for your team

The right format depends on what is actually broken. A team that is technically aligned but personally disconnected needs a different design than a leadership group that agrees in principle but stalls at execution. A sports team rebuilding chemistry after a rough season needs something different again. This is why a single off the shelf workshop rarely works for every group. The people, the behaviors that need to shift, and the stakes involved are different every time.

What stays constant is the underlying requirement: real interdependence, real consequences, and a direct line back to the actual work. Any option that includes those three elements is worth considering. Any option missing one of them is likely to produce a good afternoon and very little else.

If your team needs more than a good afternoon, Morrison Alley builds custom experiential programs around your people, your goals, and a setting with a story worth stepping into. Reach out with a sentence or two about what has to change, and we will build the experience around it.

What is the best option for trust building?

The best option for trust building is a shared experience with real stakes, where a team has to solve a problem together and the outcome actually matters. Trust is built by giving people a reason to rely on each other and watching what happens when they do.

Why do traditional trust-building exercises fall short?

Classic trust falls, icebreaker questionnaires, and half-day workshops fall short because they do not ask anything real of the people in the room. There is no actual risk, no real consequence, and no shared outcome that anyone has to protect afterward. Adults retain and apply what they learn through action, reflection, and real-world application.

What separates a real trust-building experience from a gimmick?

A real trust-building experience requires genuine interdependence, an outcome that carries weight, and an honest connection to the team’s actual work. If one person can solve the puzzle alone, if falling short costs nothing, or if the activity feels decorative, the trust-building effect does not transfer.

How do you measure whether trust building actually worked?

Check whether people can describe the team’s purpose in roughly the same words, whether they have agreed out loud to a shared direction, whether the team covers ground faster, and whether leaders turn intention into action once the first busy week hits. If the first two are missing within a few weeks, the activity entertained people without changing anything.

Sources. Paul J. Zak, The Neuroscience of Trust, Harvard Business Review 95, no. 1 (2017): 84 to 90. Google re:Work, Understand team effectiveness (Project Aristotle, originally published 2015), a study of one hundred eighty teams. Gallup, State of the Global Workplace: 2023 Report, which found twenty-three percent of employees worldwide engaged at work in 2022. Malcolm S. Knowles, The Adult Learner, on andragogy and learning through action. Additional research on trust, engagement, and experiential design is gathered on our Why It Works page.

Start a conversation

If your team needs more than a good afternoon, a sentence or two about what has to change is enough to begin.

Get in touch →

All field notes

Morrison Alley Leadership Boulder, Colorado