Business simulations for senior leaders: the next practice most companies skip

A business simulation for senior leaders recreates a realistic business situation, such as a market shift, a supplier crisis, or a strategy rollout, so an executive team can make decisions, see consequences, and refine how it works together without real-world risk. Research from the Association for Talent Development (ATD) and the Institute for Corporate Productivity (i4cp) found that fewer than one in five companies use live simulations to develop leaders, yet every simulation format studied for senior leaders was strongly correlated with both market performance and learning effectiveness.

i4cp calls practices like this “next practices”: approaches that few organizations use but that are closely tied to strong results. For executive teams looking for an edge in how they develop, simulations may be the clearest example in the research.

What is a business simulation, and how is it different from a serious game?

The ATD and i4cp study defines simulations as experiences that replicate processes, events, locations, or situations to provide interactive learning with controlled risk. They can run live, virtually, or as a blend of the two.

Serious games are simulations with game elements added: a story, goals, feedback, and play. The study treats the two together, and so does this article.

At the executive level, the most valuable simulations go well beyond a training exercise. Susan Burnett, a member of the i4cp Thought Leader Consortium, described senior-level simulations as complex business model and strategy execution scenarios with leadership challenges built in, as they are in real life. Burnett also suggested a powerful use case: having executive teams run a mock execution of a strategy before launching it, the way the military rehearses an engagement before deployment. Teams that do this can find and fix the missing pieces of their execution plans before those gaps cost anything.

How many organizations use simulations to develop leaders?

Very few. According to the study:

  • Fewer than one in five organizations use live simulations to develop leaders at either the senior or frontline level.
  • Only about twelve percent use virtual simulations.
  • For senior leaders specifically, eighteen percent use live simulations, thirteen percent use virtual simulations, and fourteen percent use a blend.
  • Only sixteen percent said their organization currently uses simulations or serious games for leadership development to a high extent.

High-performing organizations stand apart. More than thirty percent of high performers use live simulations, and about one in four use virtual or blended simulations for leaders at both levels. The blended live and virtual approach was highly correlated with both market performance and learning effectiveness.

Why are simulations considered a next practice?

Two conditions define a next practice in i4cp research: limited use and strong correlation with performance. Simulations meet both.

For senior leader development, live, virtual, and blended simulations all showed extremely high correlations with market performance and learning effectiveness. Because so few organizations use them, the study’s authors noted that their limited reach offers real opportunity for organizations to build a competitive advantage in how they develop leaders.

For frontline leaders, the study identified several simulation-related next practices, including virtual simulations, blended simulations, simulations customized for the organization by a vendor, and simulations focused on talent management skills. Measuring the development that results from simulations showed the most robust correlations of all.

What skills do executive simulations develop?

Among organizations using simulations for senior leaders, the most common focus areas were:

  • Strategic and decision-making skills (thirty-nine percent).
  • Handling high-pressure situations, such as adverse events or complex change initiatives (thirty-four percent).
  • Social and interpersonal skills (thirty-three percent).
  • Talent management skills (twenty-seven percent).

All four focus areas were strongly correlated with learning effectiveness.

The pressure dimension deserves attention. High-performing organizations in the study were more than three times as likely as lower performers to cite better performance in stressful or high-pressure situations as a reason for using experiential learning. Loretta Hoepfner, then manager of training and quality systems at ABET, interviewed for the study, summed up the logic: “No capable leader wants to be caught unprepared.” A simulation lets a team rehearse the hard moment before it arrives.

What does an executive simulation look like in practice?

One example in the study shows how much a single well-designed day can accomplish. Christopher Schuller, then senior manager of learning at Boeing, described a live simulation he built earlier in his career for a fast-growing supply chain company whose business lines were not operating well together.

The company’s top leaders and their direct reports gathered off-site, organized into five teams that matched their real functions: supply chain, program management, IT, HR, and sales. Over the course of the day, the teams worked through real scenarios, such as acquiring a new customer and managing supplier problems. Each team decided what role it needed to play, then the groups came together to compare responses.

As the day progressed, the gaps became visible. One group would plan to take an action that another group assumed was its own responsibility. Conflicts in the operating model surfaced in the room, where the team could address them directly. Every issue went onto a shared list, and by the afternoon the group had assigned action items or follow-up meetings to each one.

The result was both leadership development and organizational design. Leaders saw how they communicated with their own teams and with each other, and the company left with a concrete plan to fix how it ran. “The simulation didn’t just provide a training opportunity. It had leaders actually creating solutions,” Schuller said. The learning team then held monthly meetings for six months to track the action items and test whether the solutions worked.

This example captures what makes executive simulations so effective. The scenario was built on real business problems, the whole leadership team participated together, the output was tangible, and follow-through was planned from the start.

Live, virtual, or blended: which format fits executive teams?

Each format has a role.

Live simulations put the full team in a room with real-time interaction, visible group dynamics, and immediate debriefs. They are especially strong for cross-functional executive teams, where how leaders work together is the thing being developed. Schuller noted that live experiential sessions may be the strongest strategy for executive development, because the application happens while leaders are present.

Virtual simulations offer scale, repeatability, and data. Schuller described a virtual simulation that used recorded actors reacting to leaders’ choices in a performance conversation, which helped leaders recognize emotional cues and adjust their approach.

Blended simulations combine both. The study found the blended approach highly correlated with market performance and learning effectiveness, and it is used by only about one in seven organizations for senior leaders.

Aren’t simulations expensive?

Cost is a real consideration. Twenty-seven percent of organizations using simulations for senior leaders, and twenty-eight percent for frontline leaders, said costs limit how widely they use them. Schuller acknowledged that the bigger cost is often the time of everyone involved.

He also offered a better way to frame the investment. Instead of judging a simulation by cost per participant, judge it by the business problem it solves. “You have to think about the business problem you’re solving for the company and the impact it has on performance. That’s your ROI,” he said. A simulation for ten executives may look expensive per head, but if it helps fix a flawed operating model, the return can far exceed the cost.

The study also found that simulation software developed and managed internally was the only technology significantly related to both learning effectiveness and market performance, though only fifteen percent of organizations use it. Most organizations lack the in-house capability to build custom simulations, which is why vendor-customized simulations also appear among the study’s next practices.

How should you choose a simulation partner?

Burnett offered three practical tips in the study for selecting a simulation vendor:

  1. Know what you need. The best partner for strategy execution simulations may differ from the best partner for serious games. Evaluate for the expertise your situation demands.
  2. Check the track record. Look for a reputation for performance and talk with other customers about their experience.
  3. Ask for the best people. Every firm has standout practitioners. Identify them, request them for your project, and treat them as an extension of your team.

To those, we would add one more based on the research: insist on measurement. Forty percent of high-performing organizations that use simulations make measuring their effectiveness a priority, and measurement showed significant links to market performance and learning effectiveness.

Key takeaways

  • Fewer than one in five organizations use live simulations to develop leaders, and only about twelve percent use virtual simulations.
  • Live, virtual, and blended simulations for senior leaders are all next practices, strongly correlated with market performance and learning effectiveness.
  • The most effective executive simulations are built on real business problems and involve the whole leadership team.
  • Cost concerns are best evaluated against the business problem a simulation solves.
  • High performers measure simulation outcomes and plan follow-through from the start.

Do business simulations work for executive leadership development?

In ATD and i4cp research, live, virtual, and blended simulations for senior leaders all showed extremely high correlations with market performance and learning effectiveness. They remain in limited use, which makes them a competitive opportunity.

What is the difference between a live and a virtual leadership simulation?

A live simulation brings participants together in person to work through a scenario in real time. A virtual simulation runs through software or online tools. Blended simulations combine both and were highly correlated with strong performance in the study.

What skills can an executive simulation build?

Common focus areas include strategic decision making, leading under pressure, interpersonal and collaboration skills, and talent management. Simulations built on a team’s real challenges can also surface operating model gaps.

Design a simulation around your team’s real challenge

Morrison Alley, based in Boulder, Colorado, designs custom experiential leadership and team development programs for senior executive teams, including live and blended simulations built around the decisions your team actually faces. To explore a simulation for your leadership team, contact Morrison Alley.

Related field notes: experiential learning for executive teams and what makes a leadership program actually stick.

Sources. Carol Morrison (i4cp), Experiential Learning for Leaders: Action Learning, On-the-Job Learning, Serious Games, and Simulations, Association for Talent Development and Institute for Corporate Productivity (Alexandria, VA: ATD Press, May 2016). Survey of two hundred seventy talent development professionals fielded January 2016. A public preview of the findings is also on the ATD research blog. Quotations are from interviews conducted for the report; titles reflect each speaker’s role at the time of the study. Recommendations that go beyond the research are labeled as Morrison Alley’s. Additional research on experiential learning and team performance is gathered on our Why It Works page.

Start a conversation

If your executive team has a strategy to rehearse or a hard moment to prepare for, a sentence or two is enough to begin.

Get in touch →

All field notes

Morrison Alley Leadership Boulder, Colorado